obstinatecondolement: Deanna Troi from Star Trek: The Next Generation shown from the shoulders up, standing in front of a painting of a planet (Default)

Challenge #7

Make a list of fannish and/or creative resources. Post your answer to today’s challenge in your own space and leave a comment in this post saying you did it. Include a link to your post if you feel comfortable doing so.

I was struggling with this, because I was thinking mostly of the 'creative' half of the challenge as opposed to more general fannish resources, but I think that refocusing more on the, for want of a better way to put it, 'user' experience of fandom this is a pretty useful list. There are some that are more focused on being a fanwork creator, but they are not craft/creative-focused resources so much as ways to streamline posting to AO3, etc. As a disclaimer, since a lot of this post relates to AO3, I am an OTW volunteer, but I am not speaking on behalf of the OTW in this post and the views and advice are purely my own, and may not reflect those of the OTW as an organisation (and may even be mistaken, if I have misunderstood or misremembered something). Also, I've linked some third-party scripts and extensions that customise the UX and/or UI of AO3, but please note that these are not officially affiliated with AO3 or the OTW and I am recommending them as an ordinary user of the site rather than endorsing them on behalf of the OTW.

Click to expand

That said though, here are some resources:

  1. AO3 search and filtering
  2. Maybe this one is super obvious, but AO3's native search and filtering options are very sophisticated and include options for sorting by kudos/comments/bookmarks/date posted, including/excluding certain tags from your search results, including/excluding crossovers/showing only crossovers, as well as filtering for complete/incomplete works only, works in a specific language, works in a specific word count range, works posted within a specific time period, etc.

    If you are not already using filters to refine your search results, and have been frustrated by having to search a long time to find something you're interested manually, upping your filtering game can really help you find exactly what you are interested in much more quickly.

  3. Hidden search operators cheatsheet for AO3
  4. To make AO3's filtering even more sophisticated, you can use these search operators, which will help you get even more precisely filtered results.

  5. Ao3 first tag search by Peter MacDonald
  6. If you are a rarepair shipper who is used to having to look through pages upon pages of search results when you filter for your OTP, because they only appear as a background ship in most of the works they're tagged in, then this is a great browser extension to have installed. When it's enabled, it will add a ticky box on the AO3 search page to only return works where the ship you are searching for is tagged first. Most creators on AO3 tag the 'primary' ship in a work first, so this will mean that most results will probably give you works where your ship is the focus of the work.

    You can install it here for Firefox or here for Chrome (I strongly advise switching to Firefox, by the way, but I will not bully you if you don't wanna).

  7. AO3 floating comment box by [tumblr.com profile] ravenel
  8. While I am a big believer in the validity of lurking and the fact that no one owes you a comment no matter how much they liked your work, I do want to get better at leaving comments more often and this script has really helped with that a lot. A big issue for me is that the comment box is at the very bottom of AO3 works and if I want to comment on specific parts there can be a lot of scrolling up and down to copy and paste, or refresh my memory, when I get to writing out my comment. I could keep notes in Notepad or something as I went, but realistically I don't think it's very likely I would remember to do that and even the negligible barrier to entry of opening up Notepad would make commenting seem less approachable and more difficult.

    This script really streamlines the process of commenting for me. After you have downloaded and enabled the script with Tampermonkey, you should see a little 'O' in the top lefthand corner of AO3 works you have open. If you click on this, it will open a floating comment box (which you can minimise again without losing your notes) to start writing your comment as you go. If you highlight text in the work and click "Insert selection" it will copy and paste that text into the floating box. If you click "Add to comment box" everything you've written in the floating box will be transferred to the comment box at the end of the page, which you can then mess around with some more, if you like, or just click post. And then you're done! I like this script a lot and it's really opened up writing longer more detailed comments to me.

    Here's a post by [tumblr.com profile] ravenel on Tumblr about the script. Here is the script itself on Pastebin. And if you are new to installing scripts with Tampermonkey, [tumblr.com profile] bourbon-ontherocks has a tutorial about how to install this script here.

  9. Muting and blocking on AO3
  10. I was talking to someone the other day who didn't know this, but you can now mute and/or block certain users on AO3 itself, rather than by creating a site skin yourself that hides their content, or using third-party extensions.

    From the relevant AO3 News Posts themselves, muting someone will hide:

    • works they've created (or co-created) in search results and tag listings (you can still access the works themselves, if you have a direct link)
    • bookmarks they've created
    • other users' bookmarks of their works or series
    • comments they've left
    AO3 News, "Introducing the ability to mute users" Published: 2023-02-06 00:49:38 UTC

    and when you block someone:

    "[...] they will no longer be able to comment on your works or reply to comments you've left on news posts or other creators' works. They will also be unable to edit existing comments or replies they've left you.

    The block will persist even if the blocked user changes their name."

    AO3 News, "Comment blocking is coming" Published: 2022-06-05 00:15:20 UTC (as of 20:59 UTC 10 June 2022 the changes mentioned in this News Post were deployed).
  11. Site skin to hide stats/inbox from dashboard*
  12. I got a bit overwhelmed in 2023 by my relationship to Feedback™/the response a work I posted got, or didn't get, immediately after I posted it, so I turned off emails for comments in my settings on AO3, and created a site skin that hides my inbox on the dashboard and homepage, as well as hiding the comment/kudos/bookmark count on works, and hiding most of the information on the stats page (I kept word count, because that wasn't making me go weird and I like to see it). My intention at the time was to keep the skin on most of the time and toggle it off once a week to respond to any comments and then toggle it back on, to stop getting random spikes of excitement/disappointment based on seeing my inbox, which I did for a while, but now I mostly have it off because I think (for now) I've managed to achieve a healthier relationship with this stuff.

    To figure out how to make a skin that did what I wanted it to do, I referred to:

  13. Podfic work skin by [archiveofourown.org profile] Azdaema
  14. Speaking of skins, you can use work skins on individual works you upload to alter their appearance. Sometimes people have work skins that format text messages to look as they would on a phone, etc., and a lot of podficcers use work skins on their podfics, particularly if they have cover art. You do not by any means have to make cover art or use a work skin to post podfic, and plenty of people don't, but if you do want to use a work skin to format your works when you post podfic to AO3, this skin by [archiveofourown.org profile] Azdaema lays things out nicely.

  15. AO3 podfic posting helper by [archiveofourown.org profile] irrationalpie, [archiveofourown.org profile] lastonetheboat, and Jeremy Mowery
  16. It is often common practice when posting podfic to AO3 to copy the metadata tags of the original work, as well as adding some of your own like "Podfic" or "Podfic length: 0-10 minutes" and so on, but doing this manually can be a bit tedious. This browser extension, which is available on Chrome, Firefox, Microsoft Edge, and some browser I don't know called Source, automatically copies over the metadata from the work your work was inspired by, and, optionally, adds some of your own. You can further customise this in advanced options.

  17. Blanket permission highlighter by [archiveofourown.org profile] BrickGrass
  18. If you are a podficcer, a fic translator, or anyone interested in creating works inspired by other fanworks on AO3, you are probably aware that it is common etiquette to ask permission from the original creator before you do this. Some people have a blanket statement about their transformative works policy—which might be a blanket yes, but could also be a blanket no/yes-for-X, no-for-Y, ask-me-about-Z—for people to refer to instead of having to ask for every individual transformative work they create. This is often, although not always, in their AO3 profile. You can check someone's profile manually, but there is a database of creators with blanket permission statements created/maintained by [archiveofourown.org profile] Rindle and if you install this add-on by [archiveofourown.org profile] BrickGrass, creators on listed on FPSlist will have their usernames highlighted in green on AO3. You can also, optionally, tick a box on the side panel with filters to hide works by creators who are not on the FPSlist, if you wanted to browse through a specific tag quickly to see at a glance what works were created with blanket permission. I found this very helpful when scouting out fic to podfic for ITPE, especially when combining it with using exclusion filters to filter out tags relating to a recipient's DNWs.

  19. Blanket permission builder by [tumblr.com profile] flamingwell
  20. Speaking of blanket permission, if you are a fanwork creator who would like to put together a blanket permission statement but are finding it hard to figure out the ins and outs of what you want to have on there, this tool will help you build and generate one based on your replies to a list of questions. [tumblr.com profile] fanworkspermissionstatement has an FAQ about the tool here and the tool itself can be found here

Since a lot of these ended up to relate to podfic, here's some bonus resouces for the pod-curious who want to dip their toes in the water but are worried about buying expensive equipment or software.

  • Software: Audacity is a free, open-source audio editing software and is the software most podifccers I know use.
  • Mic: your phone or your laptop's inbuilt mic.

That's it! If you have a headset mic, or a Zoom mic or something that you'd like to use instead: use that, but do not go out and spend money on anything before you've recorded a few podfics and decided if you like it. Also, for what it's worth, the audio quality of smartphone mics is very good and some of my favourite pods that I've done were things I recorded on my phone. Also, I've listened to multiple things recorded with inbuild laptop mics and I wouldn't have known if I hadn't been told, and I have a pretty good ear. This is an amateur hobby and I promise that you do not need to break the bank to just get started.

Bonus-bonus podfic resource:

  • Using a free teleprompter app like Imaginary Teleprompter frees you up from scrolling while you're reading through your script. It's helped me a lot!

*This just kept eating the rest of the post when I tried to put it higher, but if you would like to copy and paste my skin, the CSS can be found below. (Edit: I figured the problem out. I was missing an angled bracked when I was closing off the textarea element in the HTML for the form, but I can't be assed reformatting this post again to take the footnote out now that I've gone to the bother of putting it in, lol)


[return to where you left off.]

As with my last post for the [community profile] snowflake_challenge, there are a lot of links in this, so let me know if any are broken and I'll fix them.

obstinatecondolement: White text against a blue blackground which reads "It's the cutting edge of politics in an extraordinarily boring way." The twelve stars of the European Union flag are pictured in the bottom left hand corner of the image (politics)
To preface this with the disclaimers that:
  • No one is obligated to comment on my fanworks or leave a kudos on them no matter how much they liked it or how many times they have revisited them
  • No one is obligated to comment on my fanworks or leave a kudos on them just because they mentioned to me somewhere other than AO3 that they really liked them
  • No one is obligated to even tell me if they discussed and enthused vocally about my fanworks in Discord servers, or elsewhere, whether I'm in them or not
That being said, I am, however, completely bewildered with the Tumblr-moving-into-Discord-era of transformative fandom and how its culture is evolving with regards talking about fanworks, both with the creator specifically and in general.

Often, people, who do not kudos or comment on things I post to AO3, who I know have accounts (and the works aren't archive locked anyway), will either privately DM me or @ me on Tumblr or in channels of Discord servers we're both in to say they really loved my newest fanwork. Often giving me really generous praise and thoughtful insights they had when they read/saw/listened to it when they do so! I talked to a friend about this and she said that she's had people draw fanart for her of fics that they didn't kudos or comment on. And that's like... obviously that's not sinister or something they are doing wrong that they should feel obliged to correct, in favour of some alternative that's more in line with what I personally prefer/find less surprising, but... it feels pretty self evident to me that it's nice for creators to have comments to look back on, all in one non-ephemeral place, which is also ideally on AO3/wherever they posted the work itself? And that Discord servers move quickly and the nice things you say there will be quickly be buried and hard to find again, which makes it unlikely for creators to be able to easily do that, unless they screenshot and archive every nice thing someone says to them about their work there, which few people would think to do in the moment, I think, except maybe in the context of a group vid-watching party or something. Also, kudos and comments bring the work further up the page when people sort by number of kudos or comments and that is helpful for the creator because it makes it more likely that more people will see it and say further nice things to them about it if they like it too.

I don't think this trend, as I have experienced it, is a "I do not want to be seen publicly liking this" thing, which, in fairness, I do think also happens a lot in this moral panic era of fandom we're in where people get call-out posts written about how they commented on or kudosed Reprehensible Fic that the call-out post author specifically sought out so they could read the comments and see who kudosed it with the intention of smearing them as a bigot and/or sexual predator on social media platforms that their AO3 profile was linked to.

Instead, I think that, when this has happened when I posted fanworks in the past, it's just because it does not occur to the people saying the nice things to me that the I would maybe also like to have the exact same nice things written in a comment on AO3. Or similar things! I'm really not saying that you can only comment on AO3 to say something to someone that they thing they made was good. Or that squeeing about it elsewhere Does Nothing to Boost Engagement™ and is therefore useless at best and Greedy Exploitation of My Fandom Labour™ at worst, as I have seen some people arguing.

Again, you can enjoy my stuff and never say a goddamn thing about it to me, or to anyone, and I will defend to the death your right to do so, no matter what your reasons are or how often you return to these works! You do not have to pay for your enjoyment of my work by Engaging Meaningfully with it in the way that I most prefer: I am not your grandparent passive aggressively asking if you forgot to send me a thank you note about the birthday present I sent you and do you need new stationery to send thank you notes? Should I send you that for your next present?

But... Idk, exactly. I guess, to me, it's kind of emblematic of this move to considering only new fanworks and fandoms of recently released/currently airing properties to matter? So if the nice things you say about them are ephemeral and hard to archive, who cares, because the creator will obviously only ever want to hear nice things about their newest work and anything else is a waste of time, and maybe even invasive and creepy à la fans of celebrities who stalk and/or harass them because they "love" them so much. Also, that fanworks and fannish interactions are disposable and trivial, and preserving them is not ever a priority or even a consideration.

Something I was surprised about when I started posting fanworks in multifandom comms on Dreamwidth was that people commented on them at all. Often when they don't even know the fandom! The culture here seems to be much more old school in that way than what I have become accustomed to post-LJ, which has been a nice thing to discover.

I do think that this bemusement I am having is not, like, something that I should fashion into a call to action or anything, in large part because I am extremely put off by the people who scold lurkers—or sometimes even people who don't comment effusively enough, or leave long enough comments, or who comment and then don't also kudos (the nerve! 🙄)—for "taking the gift of their work and giving them nothing back in return as thanks" because fuck that bullshit. That is not what is meant by the phrase "fandom is a gift economy" you ignorant, entitled dicks. Is commenting on AO3 a nice thing to do? Yes. But it's not obligatory and nor should it be. At least be honest about what you expect from people and start a fucking private Discord server where you link people to your Google Docs, in return for what you consider to be good feedback if you think you should be to be compensated for your fanworks—kick them off your private island if they fail to live up to your standards, for all I care! But do not put words in my mouth by saying this fucking shit on behalf of all creators who post things to AO3.


Really, I'm not sure what my point is here, exactly. I am having thoughts and feelings and these are what they are, I suppose? Or, I guess, if you find yourself wanting to reach out and say nice things to a fanwork creator anyway, it's potentially a nice gesture to do it on AO3/where they posted it, in addition to saying it on Discord or other ephemeral fandom platorms. Copying and pasting exactly what you said is absolutely fine by me, if you find it a struggle to re-phrase the same sentiment. I suspect it would be by other fanwork creators too, although, per what I said earlier, I can only speak confidentally for myself, because other fanwork creators' expectations and preferences vary considerably. You can add something like "C&P-ing from Discord for posterity" at the start of the comment if you feel shy about saying literally the exact same thing twice.
obstinatecondolement: The character Mr. Messy from the Mr. Men books against a white background, similar to the cover of a Mr. Men or Little Miss book. The image is captioned, "Little Mx Executive Dysfunction." (little mx executive dysfunction)
I have done a bit of an archaelogical dig through my AO3 account and Google Drive to determine what days I wrote during February, so I could finally update my GYWO tracking spreadsheet for this month, before I had to do it in a desperate scramble at the end of the month when the check-in form went live.

Currently, I am on track for my annual goal and very slightly behind on my monthly goal. So I could either rest on my laurels until March, or shoot for another 6 writing days for the rest of Feb. I'll probably go for the latter, so I have a bit of a buffer built in for times when writing is just not happening.
obstinatecondolement: A meter similar to a speedometer colour coded from green up to red in various gradations of colour, each with an image of a chili pepper on them. The needle is pointing to the extreme red end of the scale. The caption reads, "Mild auism? Nah, my autism is spicy." Flames appear behind the text (spicy autism)
I used to get very preoccupied with the idea that I was personally responsible for increasing the representation of f/f and f/m fanworks through my output, largely because of moral scrupulosity OCD brain. I don't feel the same way anymore.
That said...However, I do think, "I just coincidentally only ship m/m ships ¯\_(ツ)_/¯" can be a cop out and attempts to explain m/m's overrepresentation in the works posted to AO3 as, "male characters are typically the only ones given the depth and dimension which lends itself to shipping" is, in my opinion, disingenuous when you consider how ready, willing and able fandom is to invent characterisation out of whole cloth for minor male characters and shippable dynamics between male characters, who may never share screentime together or reference each other in dialogue, that just do not exist in the source material. I would like to clarify: I do not think this kind of transformation of the source material is sinister! I just think that since we can do that and we often do do that, we can, as a community, also do it for characters who are not male and ships that are not m/m more often.

I think it's worth thinking about how and why we ship what we ship and if we might have unconscious biases that make us overlook characters who are not men or ships other than m/m ships. Just so I'm not misunderstood, I'm certainly not saying that any individual has to ship things they are not enthused by or that they are obligated to Blorbify characters who do not speak to them. I'm also not saying that individual fans have to meet a quota of different ship categories or that they are personally responsible for increasing the representation of a diverse category of ships on AO3. Additionally, I'm not saying that the answer to the question, "Why do I mostly ship m/m?" is always, "Because I overlook and undervalue characters who are not men." Sometimes it's, "because I am primarily or exclusively attracted to men and ships featuring characters I am not myself attracted to do not interest me" or, "because I mostly read/write explicit fic and explicit fic about women makes me dysphoric" or, "because the kinds of characters I tend to be drawn to are seldom not male" or any number of other perfectly valid reasons. Again, this is a big picture issue, not a problem with individual fans' preferences. Note: the focus of this post is gender, but there are obviously many other forms of diversity that can be represented in fanworks. I took this as my primary focus mainly because the default ship categories make it easier to look at numbers for this particular kind of diverse representation.

[EDIT Jan 22 2023: I think that I could have expressed myself better in the above here. For one, I think that my use of the word "we" implies that I think everyone reading this post is primarily an m/m shipper or someone whose favourite characters are all men, which is obviously not the case. I meant "we" in the sense of "transformative fandom on AO3 collectively" which does disproprortionately favour m/m and male characters. I think I also neglected to say that people should create for and engage with ships and characters that they like! I said that no one is obligated to create for or engage with things they don't like, but that still leaves room for the interpretation that it would be a good thing for them to prioritise increasing representation at the expense of having fun anyway even if they chose not to do it. That's not at all what I want! I think that we could all be having even more fun, basically, and that people who primarily or exclusively like m/m ships and male characters are potentially missing out on fun that they could be having. Also, that people who like ships involving characters who are not men or fans of non-male characters are potentially missing out on friends, community and fanworks that they could have if transformative fandom as a whole was less weighted towards m/m ships and male characters.]

So you said something about a self audit? What do you mean by that? )

A final note: I in no way would expect anyone to examine their fannish output in this level of detail I have here, or at all, and I don't think that I'm being morally virtuous by doing so myself. I'm just really fascinated by data and this kind of thing is interesting and fun for me. Also, to reiterate, shipping is not activism and your fannish output is not necessarily a reflection of your politics or values. While I would personally like to diversify my output in the future, and I think that as a community transformative fandom would be better served by a more diverse offering of fanworks, I don't think that anyone is bad or wrong for liking what they like.

Profile

obstinatecondolement: Deanna Troi from Star Trek: The Next Generation shown from the shoulders up, standing in front of a painting of a planet (Default)
Art

October 2024

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
131415 16171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 14th, 2025 05:45 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios